In my first post on principles, I had an entry regarding problem solving – specifically, guidance on defining problems. That entry is actually a condensed version of something I have hanging in my cubicle at work:
I printed the post from a Lifehacker article, and have since annotated it with a few extra ideas. On the left, I stole a line from Tim Ferriss’s Tribe of Mentors to supplement the step for generating possible solutions to your problem. The simplicity of the question, “what would this look like if it were easy?” allows me to limit the choice pool by excluding unlikely scenarios while thinking about the positive outcomes.
When it comes to evaluation consequences and narrowing down the options, I have added three additional tools. First, I borrow again from Tim Ferriss where he uses “Fear Setting” to determine the worst case scenarios possible, and then he goes through each outcome and asks himself whether the cost is something that he could live with. By doing so, he reframes his concerns away from merely worrying about negative outcomes to only focus on the things that matter to him.
I also added a note to myself to ensure I’m capturing my assumptions. A lot of the time I start with my conclusions and assume they are transparent in their reasoning. However, if I ask a series of clarifying questions (usually the 5-why technique), I often end up drilling down to hidden assumptions or emotions that motivate the conclusion (rather than pure reason).
The final note I scribbled is in reference to Enrico Fermi who had an uncanny knack making stunningly accurate “guesses” off the top of his head. Fermi used probabilities and statistics to make educated guesses to solve problems, which could then be further refined. It’s a tool for quick and dirty estimates, and it helps to narrow down the choice pool.
My annotations aim at four tools I can use to supplement Kranz’s method: what is the best/easiest solution, what’s the absolute worst case, how easily can we figure this out, and what motivations are driving my decisions. I try to keep those considerations in mind, though I’m not nearly as rational as I pretend to be.
Since my last post on principles, I’ve jotted down a few more ideas in my notebook. I’ve transcribed my thoughts under the photo below.
6. Where appropriate, seek to reduce or limit choice pools.
a.) Too many choices is paralyzing.
b.) Extraneous choices impacts rank(ing) orders.
c.) Choice + paralysis will cause decision friction –> procrastination, and inertia will grind things to a halt.
d.) Time and resources get wasted in the decision process –> you trade off value.
e.) Most decisions can be whittled down by routine and quick preference (gut reaction) –> use 80/20.
f.) Invest time in deliberation for high stakes outcomes or decisions that interest you.
i.) Also invest when decision process is educative for you.
This entry largely captures what my behaviours are like when it comes to making decisions versus where I want them to be. By nature, I’m a risk averse and indecisive person. I tend to sit on decisions far too long, to the point where they can cause anxiety when it’s finally time for me to make the call.
I also tend to lack preferences in a lot of things. For instance, I usually don’t have a strong preference when it comes to picking a place to eat, so I’m terrible at deciding where to go but I’m perfectly happy to go along with choices made by others. There are many things I’m starkly black-and-white about (which is really annoying to my wife), but most of the time I sit in a middle state like Buridan’s ass.
Therefore, this set of principled notes captures where I want to be – to quickly narrow down extraneous choices (because too many options usually leads to diminished outcomes), and to automate where I can. Then, I can focus on the really important decisions or use the deliberation process as a teaching tool for myself.
Happy Labour Day! Things have been busy here at work while we gear up for the new academic year. Students are around, schedules are messed up, and people are scrambling to get back into the right mindset to kick off the new term. Things are bustling and busy.
I don’t intent to keep a post trend going, but I wanted to ride some of the wave from last week’s psych-out post and talk about another recent failure I experienced at work.
Last week, I had to give a short presentation to college faculty about the research ethics board I’m on. The purpose of the presentation was to remind faculty that the board exists, and to have them consider whether an ethics review is needed for their or their student’s projects. I had a 15-minute block of time and a slide-deck provided by our board coordinator.
After the presentation, I sat down and wrote out all the ways the presentation sucked. In fairness, two of my colleagues went out of their way to complement my presentation, and that they took away the two main deliverables (that student research projects should be run by the board, and that I’m available on campus to answer questions). I checked in with my boss and she, too, agreed that the presentation was not a failure as I saw it. I know that my perception of how things went will be dramatically different than how others perceive me. Nevertheless, I know that I am capable of doing much better and the main culprit of my failure was because I didn’t practice out loud before the talk.
Here is the list I generated:
Everything that went wrong (and why):
- Didn’t practice the slides
- Didn’t build the deck (it was pre-made and sent to me; building the deck would have made me more familiar with the content by necessity)
- Too rushed
- Unstable speaking patterns (rambling ticks)
- Poor intro
- Poor conclusion
- Didn’t plan my transitions
- Didn’t know how the transitions were set in the slide (i.e. need to click to reveal text)
- Missed content from the page.
- Had to look at screen to figure out where I was
- Didn’t know I’d have to hold a microphone (I knew this from past All Faculty meetings, but I should have anticipated it)
- I was holding the mic and the presentation remote – my hands were full
- Didn’t pause to calm down or collect my thoughts
- Bad presentation but saved with good will from prior relationships with faculty + my position (junior to the faculty)
- finished in 8min or 15min.
- Didn’t have a firm point in mind that I wanted them to take away from talk.
- Didn’t edit slides to remove non-essential content
You can’t win them all, but it’s important to know where you go wrong so you don’t make the same mistakes again.
Yesterday I went to a climbing gym with my co-workers for our summer staff party. It’s been at least five years since the last time I tried rock climbing, and over a decade since the last time I actually climbed a rockface.
The experience was interesting. On the one hand, the venue is great, and the staff were awesome. My co-workers were all super supportive, and in no way did I feel like I didn’t belong because of other people. I did, however, felt like I didn’t belong because I’m a 325lbs mass of meat that doesn’t have the greatest cardiovascular system and a nervous suspicion of gravity.
I made two attempts to climb a fairly easy 5.5 wall. The first attempt, I chickened out about a quarter of the way up. A little while later, I made a second attempt and got around 80% of the way up before I stopped, thought about things, and promptly started climbing back down. In other words, I psyched myself out before I reached the top.
I was really bummed out about it afterward, because I knew that if I pushed through the mental barrier and went up the last 5-10 feet, I could have made it. Instead, I saw that I still had a bit to go and felt that I didn’t trust the auto-belay device to support my weight, and the hand-holds near the top would have been tricky to climb back down on. So, instead I decided to turn back and climb down until I was a safe height up from the ground where I could let go and still not injure myself if the auto-belay device didn’t arrest me.
It’s really stupid to let myself succumb to this kind of thinking. I know that the equipment is safe, and I know that I won’t injure myself if I slip. Nevertheless, I let my fear get the best of me, and I turned back before the end.
We can’t win them all. I’ll try to do better next time.